Method to Madness Has a New Home!

Method to Madness Has a New Home!
We have moved! Click on the banner above to join us for new content from 2021 to present!
Showing posts with label CW. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CW. Show all posts

REVIEW -- Supergirl (Season One)


Supergirl is an American superhero action-adventure drama television series developed by Ali Adler, Greg Berlanti and Andrew Kreisberg (the latter two having previously created Arrow and The Flash) that originally aired on CBS and premiered on October 26, 2015. It is based on the DC Comics character Supergirl (Kara Zor-El), created by Otto Binder and Al Plastino, and stars Melissa Benoist in the title role. Supergirl is a costumed superheroine who is the biological cousin to Superman and one of the last surviving Kryptonians.

Recurring Cast


Melissa Benoist as Kara Zor-El / Kara Danvers / Supergirl
Mehcad Brooks as James Olsen
Chyler Leigh as Alex Danvers
Jeremy Jordan as Winslow "Winn" Schott, Jr.
David Harewood as Hank Henshaw and J'onn J'onzz / Martian Manhunter
Calista Flockhart as Cat Grant
Floriana Lima as Maggie Sawyer
Chris Wood as Mon-El

Premise


Kara Zor-El (Melissa Benoist) was sent to Earth from the doomed planet Krypton as a 12-year-old by her parents Zor-El (Robert Gant) and Alura (Laura Benanti). Alura gave her instructions to protect her infant cousin Kal-El, and informed her that she, like her cousin, would have extraordinary powers under Earth's yellow sun.

En route to Earth, Kara's spacecraft was diverted by a shock wave from Krypton's explosion and forced into the Phantom Zone, where it stayed for 24 years. During this period, time stopped for Kara so, when the spacecraft eventually escaped the Phantom Zone, she still appeared to be a 13-year-old girl. By the time the spacecraft crash landed on Earth, Kal-El had grown up and becomeSuperman. After helping her out of the craft, Superman took Kara to be adopted by his friends, the Danvers family. The main series begins more than a decade later when the now 24-year-old Kara is learning to embrace her powers after previously hiding them.[2]

Kara hid her powers for more than a decade, believing that Earth didn't need another hero. However, she has to reveal her powers to thwart an unexpected disaster, setting her on her own journey of heroism as National City's protector.[3] Kara discovers that hundreds of the criminals her mother prosecuted as a judge on Krypton are hiding on Earth, including her mother's twin sister Astra (also played by Benanti) and Astra's husband Non (Chris Vance), who seek to rule the world. After briefly becoming suspicious of the true agenda of her boss, Hank Henshaw (David Harewood), she and her adoptive sister, Alex Danvers (Chyler Leigh), secretly discover that Henshaw is actually a benevolent alien refugee, J'onn J'onzz, who has resided on Earth for over fifty years after escaping a holocaust on his homeworld of Mars. J'onn infiltrated the DEO to reform the organization as well as to watch over both Alex and Kara in addition to guiding the latter in the use of her powers due to his experience with his own abilities. Kara is also being targeted by Earth's criminals as the result of her being related to Superman, and later on encounters an emerging community ofmetahumans and individuals from parallel universes. In the process, Kara accumulates her own rogues gallery who seeks to defeat and destroy her. She is aided by a few close friends and family who guard her secrets—most notably her cousin's longtime friend,James Olsen (Mehcad Brooks)—which also serves as a major plot in high tech mogul Maxwell Lord's (Peter Facinelli) scheme to expose Kara's identity.

Episode List


Episode 1 - "Pilot"


A young girl named Kara Zor-El is sent to Earth by her mother Alura to protect her cousin, Kal-El, as their planet, Krypton, destructs. The planet's explosion forces her ship off course and into the Phantom Zone for 24 years, before landing on Earth. Kal-El, now an adult and going by the name Superman, puts Kara in the care of the Danvers. Twelve years later, Kara reveals herself to the world when her adoptive sister's plane is sabotaged. Her sister, Alex, works at the Department of Extra-Normal Operations, under the leadership of Hank Henshaw, investigating alien activity. Kara learns that there are hundreds of aliens on the planet in hiding, most whom came from a prison that crashed on Earth, and that her mother was the one responsible for imprisoning them. Her actions attract the attention of Vartox (Owain Yeoman), and she is able to defeat him. New art director James Olsen reveals he was sent to look after her and presents Kara with a new cape. Vartox's superior is revealed to be Astra In-Ze, Alura's identical twin sister, who wants to conquer Earth.

Episode 2 - "Stronger Together"


In an effort to put a positive image on Supergirl in the wake of a serious mishap, Kara asks Winn and James to help her perfect her skills, while Hank and Alex put Kara through extensive physical training. Kara learns that an alien (Justice Leak) of the Hellgrammite species who escaped from Fort Rozz is on Earth searching for chlorine-based food. The DEO prepares an ambush for the Hellgrammite, but it escapes, kidnaps Alex, and takes her to Astra. Astra uses Alex as a trap for Kara. As Kara and Astra fight, Hank injures Astra with a Kryptonite knife and Alex kills the Hellgrammite. Learning that Kara has become more powerful than she had imagined and that humanity has a means of weakening Kryptonians, Astra muses that her "plans" may need to be postponed. Cat pressures James to get her an interview with Supergirl. James has reservations about being used as a go-between to his superpowered friends, while Kara is worried about being recognized. In the end, Kara agrees to the interview and prevents James from getting fired. It is also revealed that Hank might have a secret of his own when his eyes begin to glow red.

Episode 3 - "Fight or Flight"


During the interview with Cat, Supergirl accidentally reveals that she is Superman's cousin. Supergirl is later attacked by Reactron (Chris Browning), who seeks to kill her in order to get his revenge on Superman, but she manages to send him fleeing. He later goes to LORD Technology labs and kidnaps Maxwell Lord to get him to fix his suit. Kara later learns that a reactor meltdown Superman stopped in the past killed Reactron's wife, thus explaining the vendetta. She goes to Reactron's hideout and manages to save Maxwell Lord, only to get badly injured by Reactron afterwards, but Superman comes to save her. She gets mad at James, who called Superman for help, as she didn't want to rely on the Man of Steel. During a party Cat organized, Reactron breaks in to find Supergirl. While James distracts Reactron, Supergirl covers her hand in lead so that she can use it to safely remove the power core in Reactron's suit and defeat him. It is later revealed that James has an ex-fiancée, Lucy Lane (the younger sister of Lois Lane), who came to National City to patch up their relationship.


Episode 4 - "How Does She Do It?"


Cat Grant is out of town and Kara, James, and Winn struggle to take care of CatCo, Cat's son Carter, and a bomber targeting Maxwell Lord's company. The DEO, claiming to be the FBI, goes to Lord and attempts to convince him to postpone the bullet train's opening, but to no avail. On the opening night of Lord's new bullet train, Supergirl and the DEO must deal with two bomb threats simultaneously, one at the airport and one on the train. James and the DEO go to the airport, where Hank Henshaw secretly uses his hidden strength to deactivate the bomb. Supergirl goes to the train, on which Carter and the bomber are both riding. As Supergirl confronts the bomber, he claims that he is doing it for his daughter. The bomber requests Supergirl save the people on the train after he starts the timer. At DEO headquarters, Alex finds a fail-safe in the "dud" bomb, causing Supergirl to realize that Lord was the one behind the bomber's actions. Lord concedes that the threats could have been used to test Supergirl's skills.

Episode 5 - "Livewire"


After fighting an alien escapee, Kara meets Alex at the apartment to greet their mother, Eliza Danvers, for Thanksgiving, inviting Winn due to his lack of plans. CatCo's shock jock, Leslie Willis (Brit Morgan) is demoted by Cat to traffic reporting after a controversial bashing of Supergirl. During a severe thunderstorm, Supergirl tries to save Leslie, but lightning strikes them both, imbuing Leslie with electromagnetic powers. Leslie takes the name "Livewire" and tries to take revenge on Cat, but eventually Supergirl stops her and she is imprisoned at DEO. After Alex tells Eliza in a fit of rage at the dinner table that she's actually DEO, Eliza reveals to her daughters that, years ago, their father, Dr. Jeremiah Danvers, offered himself up to work for Hank Henshaw in exchange for Kara's safety and then died mysteriously, leading the girls to become suspicious of Henshaw.

Episode 6 - "Red Faced"


Anger issues surface for multiple characters, including Kara. Cat's mother, Katherine Grant, arrives. Lucy's father, Sam Lane (Glenn Morshower), arrives. The military's rogue combat android Red Tornado (Iddo Goldberg) challenges Kara. She and Alex eventually defeat both the robot and its creator T.O. Morrow (also portrayed by Goldberg), but the fight leaves the former weakened. It is discovered that Hank Henshaw was the last to see Jeremiah Danvers alive. At the end of the episode, Kara drops some glass and, when she picks it up, she starts bleeding.

Episode 7 - "Human for a Day"


The fight with Red Tornado leaves Kara helpless without her powers. During an earthquake, she attempts to help James and Winn, while the events allow the alien prisonerJemm (Charles Halford) to break out of his DEO cell and face off against Alex and Hank, who is later revealed to be a benevolent alien refugee, J'onn J'onzz. Hank explains to Alex that her father saved him from the real Henshaw, who tried to kill him and that he made him a promise to watch over his daughter. Kara is later attacked by Astra and her assistants.

Episode 8 - "Hostile Takeover"


Kara's battle against Astra is muddied when Astra explains how Alura captured her, but Kara refuses to believe her story until she discovers the truth that her mother was trying to keep from her. It is also revealed that Astra used her fight against Supergirl as part of a plan to take over Lord Technologies, led by her husband Non (Chris Vance) and his army of Kryptonians, prompting Alex and Hank to stop them. The Kryptonians are employing kryptonite-shielding armor to protect themselves from the substance, but Hank still manages to take out one after he revealed to him his true identity. Meanwhile Kara, James, Winn, and Lucy help Cat track down a hacker responsible for releasing Cat's e-mails, leading them to a CatCo executive who wants to oust Cat from the company. Cat reveals to Kara that she has a son that she has not seen in 24 years and later tells Kara that she knows that she is Supergirl. Kara then races over to Lord Technologies to face off against Non.

Episode 9 - "Blood Bonds"


Non defeats Supergirl and leaves with Hank/J'onn. Lord sends the DEO away from his facility, vowing to defend it himself, and returns to a secret experiment he is conducting. Non offers to trade Hank for Astra, but General Lane (placed in charge of the DEO during the emergency though Hank left Alex as acting director) refuses, tortures Astra for Non's location, and walks into a trap placed by Non. Kara is distraught over both this defeat and the fact that Cat will fire her unless she is convinced that Kara is not Supergirl. Kara goes to the DEO and talks with Astra who tells her that Alura believed her (correct) claim that Krypton was doomed, but sentenced her for her illegal methods while promising to work for her cause. Alex and Supergirl make the trade over Lane's objections and Astra orders Non to withdraw despite his numerical advantage. Later, J'onn uses his shape-shifting power to present Cat with Kara and Supergirl simultaneously, casting doubt on her initial deduction of their identities.

Episode 10 - "Childish Things"

When Winn learns that his father the Toyman (Henry Czerny) has escaped, Kara wants to help him find his father, but he's concerned it is his cross to bear. Alex convinces a reluctant Hank to use his powers to infiltrate Lord Technologies and find out what Maxwell is hiding. Cat hires Lucy as her general counsel, but James is unenthusiastic. Maxwell uses a hidden camera to spy on Kara and Alex, discovering that the two are sisters and learning Kara's secret identity. Also, Kara learns Winn is in love with her after he kisses her and runs off. Kara feels guilty for possibly ruining their friendship and tells Alex, who already knew how he felt.

Episode 11 - "Strange Visitor From Another Planet"


Kara saves an anti-alien senator named Miranda Crane (Tawny Cypress) after a mysterious creature attacks only to discover that Hank knows of the creature and wants vengeance against it for killing his family and race back on Mars. The deception takes on a new twist when the alien poses as Senator Crane in order to bait Hank into revealing the DEO's Green Martian and Kara has to intervene before Hank goes through with his vengeance. Meanwhile, Kara helps Cat meet with her son Adam who later asks Kara out for a date. An identical Supergirl suddenly shows up in National City and is already the lead story on television after she tosses a dangling car off a bridge.

Episode 12 - "Bizarro"


Kara comes face-to-face with a doppelgänger of herself (Hope Lauren) who was brought to life by Maxwell through a combination of genetics from her DNA and a comatose victim. The double is mentally programmed to destroy Supergirl. Kara, on the other hand, believes that Maxwell is the one the DEO should go after when he reveals he knows her secret by sending Bizarro out to kill her while she is Kara. Alex and Hank come up with a plan to keep Maxwell from exposing Kara while countering Bizarro with a synthetic blue kryptonite. Meanwhile, Kara starts to get to know Adam, but is not sure whether to take the next step. A mysterious plant attacks Kara.


Episode 13 - "For the Girl Who Has Everything"


A mysterious plant known as the Black Mercy places Kara in a dreamlike state that has her imagining she is back on Krypton. The plant is part of a plot by Non, who is using Earth's technology to launch Myriad, which he and Astra are planning to use to wipe out humanity. Alex, Hank, Winn, Maxwell, and James race against time to save Kara, with Alex entering Kara's mind to pull Kara out and bring her back to reality. When Kara comes back, she seeks revenge on Non and stops him, but Astra, who wanted Kara unharmed and is upset with Non, is killed by Alex before she could kill Hank, who fought her off as the Martian Manhunter. Hank tells Kara that he killed Astra instead of Alex, who starts to feel guilty over whether she should tell Kara the truth. Non vows revenge on Kara in the wake of Astra's death.


Episode 14 - "Truth, Justice, and the American Way"


Kara, Alex, and J'onn track down an armored alien known as the Master Jailer (Jeff Branson), whom they discover was a prison guard at Fort Rozz. He has become a vigilante who kills the alien fugitives, including those convicted of non-violent crimes such as a professor sentenced for drug smuggling. Kara confronts the Master Jailer, but he takes her prisoner and plans to execute her for not joining him. Alex pinpoints his location and Kara is able to save the professor and defeat the Jailer. Cat assigns James and Lucy to investigate Maxwell Lord's disappearance. Tensions between James and Lucy develop after he reveals his knowledge of the DEO, prompting James to urge Kara to release Maxwell. Kara finds competition in Cat's new "first assistant" Siobhan Smythe (Italia Ricci), who vows to become the next Cat Grant. As Kara and Non pay their final respects to Astra, Non warns her that she will be next. Kara attempts to seek out the truth about Myriad and realizes she cannot forgive J'onn for killing her aunt.

Episode 15 - "Solitude"


A hacker steals information from a cheating website and asks Cat to release it. When Cat refuses, the hacker disrupts the city's infrastructure by interfering with its computer system. The hacker is revealed to be Indigo (Laura Vandervoort), who was in Fort Rozz and enabled Kara to escape the Phantom Zone. Her true plan is to destroy National City with a nuclear missile, but her attempt is foiled by Supergirl. Meanwhile, Kara is still mad at Hank and refuses to return to the DEO. Upon realizing they are stronger together, she eventually does, only to be told by Alex that it was she who killed her aunt.

Episode 16 - "Falling"


Supergirl inadvertently comes into contact with Red Kryptonite which destroys her inhibitions. It turns out that Maxwell created it in the hopes of stopping Non's next attack. Instead, it gradually turns Supergirl evil. The DEO is able to subdue her, but at the price of Hank revealing himself as the Martian Manhunter.

Episode 17 - "Manhunter"


While Kara is trying to win back National City's trust, Marine Colonel James Harper (Eddie McClintock) begins an investigation into the J'onn affair with Lucy, having re-enlisted into the Army at her previous rank of Major, as his legal assistant. After learning that Hank and Alex are on their way to Project Cadmus, Kara tells Lucy that she is Supergirl and convinces her to help rescue Hank and Alex. Hank learns that Jeremiah is still alive, so he and Alex go on the run to find him, but not before manipulating Harper into resigning from the Marines and appointing Lucy as the acting director of the DEO. Meanwhile, Siobhan tries to get revenge on Kara for getting her fired, but gets caught and discovers that she has the power to sonic scream.

Episode 18 - "Worlds Finest"


Siobhan discovers that the women in her family are cursed with the spirit of a banshee, which can only be quieted by killing whomever wronged them. Deciding to kill Kara, Siobhan frees Livewire from captivity at the DEO and suggests they team up. Siobhan—now calling herself Silver Banshee—and Livewire kidnap Cat and wreak havoc on National City Park. With the help of The Flash (Grant Gustin), a superhero from an alternate universe (see Arrowverse), Kara is able to subdue them and win back National City's trust. Later on, Kara discovers that everyone in National City has fallen under some kind of spell, revealed by Non to be the result of Myriad.

Episode 19 - "Myriad"


The Myriad effect has taken over National City and even Superman is under control, leaving Kara, Cat, and Maxwell as the only ones immune. Now, Kara must find a way to stop Non, but Maxwell is looking at destroying the Kryptonians with a bomb at the risk of killing humans. Cat objects and prompts Kara to find an alternative. The effect brings fugitives Alex and J'onn back before Alex can tell Eliza the truth about Jeremiah and Henshaw. When Indigo senses the two returning, she defeats J'onn, but takes Alex and places her under mind control as Non's payback for Astra's death.

Episode 20 - "Better Angels"


Kara fights with Alex, who is controlled by Non. When Alex is about to kill Kara with the same sword used to kill Astra, their mother pleads with her to stop, breaking Non's control over Alex. The team learns that hope is the key to stopping Myriad. Supergirl inspires the citizens of National City, waking them from the Myriad trance. However, Non is convinced by Indigo to kill all the humans on Earth by increasing Myriad's frequency. Back at the DEO, Max warns Kara that she might not survive a solo fight with Non and Indigo; J'onn later insists on helping her. Kara and J'onn confront Non and Indigo at Fort Rozz, which is powering Myriad. Kara defeats Non in a heat vision battle and J'onn rips Indigo's body apart. As Indigo dies, she gloats that Myriad cannot be shut down. Kara flies Fort Rozz into space, rendering Myriad harmless; Alex rescues her using Kara's pod. Afterward, J'onn is reinstated as the Director of the DEO and Cat gives Kara a promotion. While Kara celebrates at her house, another pod similar to the one in which Kara came to Earth crashes near National City. Kara opens the pod and is shocked by what is inside it.

The Verdict


Boy, did this show go through some ups and downs over the course of it’s premiere season.  At it’s core, it’s just like the other shows from the CW based in the “Arrowverse”, even though ironically it doesn’t take place in that same universe. I’m sure that is going to change after the change from CBS to the CW for Season 2, but geez that made things awkward for this first season.

Most episodes followed a copy and paste dry routine with the villain of the week format that The Flash seems comfortable in. The similarities to The Flash doesn’t stop there as there’s the clichéd support group to help Kara/Supergirl out (initially the DEO, then her ragtag crew of close friends and co-workers, before finally a combination of both by the end of the season), the overly happy yet optimistic protagonist (Kara/Supergirl),  and the motivational speeches and occasional moments to hit viewers right in their feelings.

That being said, if there’s anything this show does right despite anything negative I will bring up in this review it’s that this show embodies and symbolizes what it means to be a figure of hope like Supergirl better than Man of Steel and Batman vs. Superman have done to date. There are many moments throughout the course of this season where it wasn’t Kara’s awesome array of powers didn’t save the day, but it was her compassion, heart, and courageousness that won the day. The show focuses on the importance of her as a symbolic figure more than that focusing on just the powers or just the fact that she’s Superman’s cousin. In that aspect, Supergirl truly shines on her own in this show.

Speaking of negatives, can we talk about how bad the villains in this show looked in costume and how they were mishandled in the narrative?

One of my all-time favorite Superman: The Animated Series villains, Livewire was made into a random shock jock who was obsessed with Cat Grant while Silver Banshee was just disgruntled former Catco employee with issues. They completely wasted Red Tornado, then made Reactron and even Maxima (played by former WWE Diva Eve Torres) throwaway villains, despite their significance to Superman's lore. If I could slap the writers of this show, I would give them several backhands. The obsession with this seasons' main antagonist(s) being from Krypton screamed Superman II so much that it seemed like a minor inconvenience...




As much as I have frowned upon this show throughout this first season on social media yet continue to watch it just to see where it goes, I have to admit there are a few noteworthy episodes that made me glad I stuck around watching it.

Episode 7 - "Human for a Day" - One could point out of the importance that this show went out of its way to establish that Supergirl shares the same "new power" that was revealed in the comics continuity as what New 52 Superman has dubbed as the after-effects of using the Super Flare, but the biggest takeaway from this episode is the importance of Supergirl as a symbol - with or without her powers. What Kara is willing to do to drive that point home, even without her powers, is one of the best moments of this entire season.

Episode 11 - "Strange Visitor from Another Planet" - This entire episode was dedicated to exploring Manhunter's backstory and making the villain of the week feature one of his adversaries, notably a White Martian.

Kara and Barry were awesome together on this episode.
Episode 18 - "Worlds Finest" - This was the best episode all season, not because of the villains featured (Livewire again and the debuting Silver Banshee) - both villains they fucked up on a colossal scale in terms of origins and costume designs, but because of The Flash guest-starring on this episode. This episode was shown on the CBS network completely out of order as it was supposed to take place during Barry's disappearance from his own continuity alongside the airing of Season Two of his own series' parallel dimensions plot. I could've cared less about the actual superhero team-up of this episode but I couldn't get enough of how well Kara Danvers (Melissa Benoist) and Barry Allen (Grant Gustin) play off each other. It got to the point of me asking myself why they didn't do this team-up sooner? It's definitely one of the best moments all season and I hope we get more team-ups like this now that Supergirl has officially moved to the CW Network.

The Absence of Superman

For those expecting to see Superman in this show, this is the best you get. I'm not even kidding.
Right off the bat, this is the biggest critique that weighs this show down and holds it back in a sense. For a show that references and mentions Superman so much, it's mind-boggling that he would be absent from the bulk of the show and limited to communicating to Kara via instant messaging, text messages, or through Jimmy Olsen. The first few "cameos" I let them slide on but as it became an ongoing thing where Superman wasn't going to ever show up for real, I shook my head at why would they omit something so important to Kara's growth as a hero. I'm sure the feminists will argue that Superman would have brought this show down if she could call on her cousin for help in every situation, but he's her family and that was needed as she struggled to cope with this new duality of being a super-powered heroine and attempting to fit in her "normal" life.

The lack of Superman ends up being the ultimate cop out as it's painfully obvious that CBS were too cheap to pay for the Superman license to go along with having a Supergirl narrative. Given how the DC Extended Universe is going right now, I'm pretty sure that that's a pretty pricey license to try to get a hold of anyway. They probably ran into the same situation as Gotham on the Fox Network, where you have a Batman-themed TV show without having Batman in it.

Fortunately, Superman will make his official debut in Season Two on the CW Network, played by Tyler Hoechlin. That is, if fans will be willing to give this show another go after it's move to the new network.

Not really crazy about this ordinary looking dude playing Supes after we've been all
spoiled by Henry Cavill looking like he stepped off a comic book panel...


The Importance of Martian Manhunter

Spoiler Alert: Hank Henshaw is Martian Manhunter in this series.

Since they couldn't get Superman as a series regular, the writers went and did the next best thing - Martian Manhunter. J'onn isn't revealed until roughly a few episodes into the series, but his inclusion was huge for this show. He marks one of the few key pivotal members of the Justice League as part of this universe, but it's more important that Kara has someone to lean onto as support as another orphaned alien on this planet that isn't her home. Manhunter acts as the one person that Kara can identify with in terms of being a "gifted" individual in world that is strange to them, yet under their unique circumstances, has become their home that they must protect.

For those wondering... Kara's going to have even more people to identify with in the next season as Mon-El was the one in the pod that she found at the end of the Season One finale, which was confirmed a few months ago at Comic-Con.

My only complaint about Manhunter was that he looked like CGI-model ripped right out of Injustice: Gods Among Us and just conveniently placed into this show.


WTF is this shit?

Seriously... LOOK AT THIS SHIT.



I'm not even going to sugar-coat it... the action sequences in this show were fucking awful. You're going to hear me say it again in my review of Legends of Tomorrow Season 1, but Jesus Christ, don't make these superhero TV dramas when your fight sequences look worse and more campy than Batman '66 and the original seasons of Power Rangers combined. Plus, you can tell they were trying too hard to sprinkle a little of Snyder's Man of Steel action sequences into this show subtly between the lines.

I'm begging for DC to find someone better to do the fight choreography for these TV shows. Even Power Rangers has better fight scenes than this in their newer seasons, so I know there has to be a way to get something better visually here.


Cat Grant Steals the Show... Literally


When this show first aired... or rather when the pilot leaked online on various outlets, I thought Cat Grant's character was going to be a mock J. Jonah Jameson as a lot of these DC Comics-based superhero TV dramas tend to borrow a lot of themes from Spider-Man to hit home with the teen viewing audience that they are made for, but over the course of this season, she really grew on me as the best character in this show. The fanboys and fangirls will say that Melissa Benoist makes the show, but it's more Calista Flockhart's performance as Cat Grant on how she's turned into a firm believer of Supergirl after being one of her hardest critics when she first made her debut.

Throughout the season, Cat Grant ironically plays the part of the audience watching this show. She starts off as Supergirl's biggest critic in terms of who she is and what she stands for, but by the end of the season, she is Supergirl's biggest supporter, even when she doesn't have faith in herself. It's hard to support this show, even for the most hardcore of fans when it has so many negatives going for it than positives, such as it's primetime television slot during the height of Monday nights' sports - football, basketball, and WWE, how it clearly has a lower budget than most of the other CW-produced DC Comics-based shows, and some mediocre writing that fails to hook in new viewers.

If it wasn't for Cat Grant's character growth throughout this season, I seriously doubt I would have gone out of my way to bother watching this show for the complete season.

Watch It or Don't Bother

If you're not crazy about the other CW-based DC Comics superhero TV dramas, then don't bother with this. You're not missing out on anything groundbreaking. If you're willing to endure through the entire season, there's some minor rewards in terms of the reveal of Martian Manhunter and the crossover team-up with Grant Gustin as Barry Allen/The Flash from his own series, but even those standout points are asking a lot from the casual viewer to invest into watching this season in its entirety.

Supergirl tries it's best to put it's best foot forward to pay homage to this iconic heroine being the first female DC Comics character to star in her own solo superhero TV drama, but ultimately ends up falling short a few steps from truly making a lasting impact. Hopefully, fans will be willing to come back for the next season to give it another chance after the creators have time to digest what they did well and how to improve for the better.

REVIEW -- CW's The Flash (TV Series) - Season 2 Premiere: "The Man Who Saved Central City"


On Tuesday, October 4, 2015, The Flash premiered its second season on the CW Network. This episode picks up where the cliffhanger from the end of the first season left off with Barry Allen/The Flash racing off to save Central City from being swallowed up by a monstrous black hole. This episode also serves as the official debut of Atom-Smasher to the Arrowverse as former WWE Superstar Edge/Adam Copeland portrays the character in this episode.

Plot: (FULL Spoilers - Credit from Comicbook.com)

The episode opens on The Flash battling Captain Cold and Heat Wave. He dispatches the Rogues quickly, with a little last-minute help from Firestorm.

The pair head back to S.T.A.R. Labs, where everyone is delighted by their performance. Iris and Joe are there…but then so is Eddie, and even Wells. He isn’t evil, but he gets out of the wheelchair and praises Barry.

Of course, its’ all in Barry’s imagination. In reality, he’s alone in S.T.A.R. when an alarm goes off and he gets into costume and heads off to work…alone. Along the way, you see signs for Flash Day, celebrating the man who saved Central City.

At a murder scene, Barry meets Joe. Al Rothstein has been murdered. He’s a welder at the nuclear plant, and it looks like he was strangled by someone very strong and very large — but Barry’s sure it wasn’t Grodd.

Joe asks Barry if he’s going to go to Flash Day, where the mayor wants to give him a key to the city, but Barry is reluctant, suggesting he doesn’t deserve it.

Behind a wall, a mysterious man takes a photo of Barry.

At Central City PD, Cisco is helping Joe put together tech for a task force to take down metahumans. Try as he might, though, he can’t convince Captain Singh to give him a badge.

After the Captain leaves, Cisco and Joe talk about how weird Barry is being, and Joe suggests that Iris should talk him into going to Flash Day.

That night, Barry is using his super-speed to rebuild Jitters, one of a number roof local businesses damaged during the singularity event. This is something he’s been doing a lot, as Iris has heard about it and figured it out. She tells him that even though Eddie had to sacrifice that day, Barry was still a hero, and he should go to the event. She says she believes in The Flash.

Cut to a flashback, when Barry manages to stabilize the singularity but can’t close it. Professor Stein tells Ronnie that the only way to save the world is for Firestorm to fly up into the eye of the singularity and separate. Ronnie kisses Caitlin, saying he has to try, and then Firestorm merges, flies up and separates. On his way down from the Singularity, Barry manages to rescue Professor Stein but can’t see Ronnie anywhere. Both Caitlin and Stein look around for him, but all Barry can do is tell them he’s sorry.

At the Flash Day event, Cisco is surprised to see Caitlin. The mayor presents the key to the city to an (absent) Flash, with Barry showing up a little late. Shortly after he does, a man shows up and starts throwing large objects around. Cisco tries to use his “boot” on the metahuman, but the masked man just grows out of it, breaking the device. Before he does, though, Cisco has a quick vision of the villain standing in a large room with blue lightning around him.

Barry and Joe manage to turn the man back, but not stop or capture him. Before he goes, though, he briefly unmasks and Joe recognizes him as Al Rothstein.

After Rothstein makes his escape, Cisco confirms that the body remains in the coroner’s office — and that he wasn’t even in town when the particle accelerator went off.

Iris comes to ask Cisco whether anything he did might have taken out a number of machines at the hospital nearby where the fight happened. Cisco leaves to be sure he didn’t do it, and Iris tells Joe that they need to stop letting Barry push them away.

Cisco goes to visit Caitlin at her new job at Mercury Labs; he wants her to rejoin Team Flash, but she’s not up for it. He asks her instead to at least look at some evidence from the murder scene of Al Rothstein — an ID badge that appears to have no data on it.

At the police department, a lawyer comes to see Barry. He gives him a thumb drive with a video message from Dr. Wells, and says that Barry will lose S.T.A.R. (which was willed to him by Wells) if he doesn’t watch it. Barry says he won’t, and the lawyer leaves. An alarm goes off at S.T.A.R., attracting Barry. Iris, Stein and Cisco are there figuring out how the villain’s power works when Stein names the baddie Atom-Smasher.

The team uses traces ofradiactive energy to find Atom-Smasher. Barry suits up and heads out, leaving his communicator behind so they can’t reach him.

At the building where they expected to find Atom-Smasher, there he is — soaking in radiation from barrels of waste. Flash asks why he killed Rothstein, and why he looks like him, and Atom-Smasher tells him he wouldn’t believe him. The two fight briefly and when Barry starts to lose, Cisco manages to hack into the building’s systems and create a diversion to get Barry away.

He runs to S.T.A.R. and collapses, where he dreams about his childhood. Joe tries to get Barry to eat, and to deal with his emotions in a productive way. The two hug.

When Barry regains consciousness, Joe is there. He tells Barry that he needs to stop blaming himself for what happened — that everything that happened was Wells’ doing, and that both Eddie and Ronnie understood the choices they were making to help. He tells Barry that he needs to focus his late-night rebuilding on things that matter.

Barry heads to Mercury Labs to see Caitlin; they have a brief conversation, and Caitlin reinforces that Barry is a hero, that she doesn’t blame him for Ronnie’s death. She blames herself for not going away with him months before, when he wanted to. She couldn’t be around S.T.A.R. because those memories tortured her. Barry pulls out a handkerchief for her when she starts to cry and the jump drive of Wells’ message falls out. They decide to watch it together so they can face it.

On the message, Wells, tells Barry that he’s going to give him what he wants, but it won’t matter because Barry is never really happy. He gives Barry a video confession that he killed Nora Allen.

Barry calls Joe and tells him to assemble Team Flash at S.T.A.R. Shortly after that, Joe is on the phone with the district attorney, who thinks it’s enough to get Henry out of jail.

Barry turns to the team, asking them how to deal with Atom-Smasher. Caitlin suggests they try to overload Atom-Smasher with radiation.

In order to lure him out, Team Flash shines a Bat Signal-style light against the clouds. Barry runs and Atom-Smasher chases; eventually they come to a facility where Barry lures Atom-Smasher into a radiation chamber and then blows past him and out of the reactor core as Cisco fills it. Atom-Smasher can’t absorb all the radiation and eventually collapses, now at normal size. Barry goes in  to check on him, apologizing for the seemingly-lethal force, and Atom-Smasher tells him that someone named Zoom had sent him after Barry, promising to let him go home if he killed The Flash. He succumbs to the radiation.

At Iron Heights, Barry walks Henry to the car; his father is a free man. They head home, where Team Flash is having a welcome home party for Henry. Cisco even gets his honorary badge, before Stein makes a touching toast.

The joy is short-lived as Henry tells Barry he plans to leave town rather than trying to resume his life in Central City. He says that Team Flash needs Barry and the city needs The Flash, not Henry Allen’s son.

Back at S.T.A.R. the next day, Barry has put Henry on a train and comes to check in with the team. Cisco has upgraded the suit and Caitlin brags about the new security system and the fact that people will finally stop dropping in unexpectedly…which is proven wrong immediately when a man calling himself Jay Garrick arrives to tell Barry “your world is in danger.”

The Verdict: 

First things first - welcome back Flash. I think they've made fans wait long enough for Season 2 when Arrow has already started it's new season a few weeks ago. I don't dick-ride off of everything the CW does with DC Comics' characters, nor am I overly excited about Gotham nor Supergirl (especially if you've read my review on the pilot for that...), but the charm of this show hooked me enough to draw me back in for Season 2. I have my fingers crossed that the writing doesn't deteriorate like how Smallville did in later seasons, but I guess we'll have to wait and see don't we? 

We start this episode off with a fun, action-packed romp between Captain Cold and Heat Wave trying to kill the Flash, only for Firestorm to help out at the last second to put an end to their piss poor attempt to stop the Scarlet Speedster. Things quickly switch back to present day (approximately 6 months after the finale of last season) where we're stuck with an angst-filled Barry Allen, moping around and fighting crime on his own without the aid of "Team Flash" - claiming that he doesn't want to endanger the well-being of his loved ones with his crime-fighting. Yeah, we've been here before, haven't we? 

Central City is having Flash Day and Barry's not in a celebrating mood. Watching this I felt like I was watching a Bizarro World version of Spider-Man 3 (Sam Raimi version) where they were celebrating Spider-Man but Peter's loved ones (namely Mary Jane) wasn't into it. In this version, Barry's playing the part of the buzzkill. To be fair, Barry's got a good reason to be down in the dumps as he blames Ronnie's death (or what we're thought to believe as his demise...) on himself during the black hole event during the finale that was conveniently explained in a short flashback. To be honest, I think the only reason that they had Ronnie be written off as "dead" was to act as the catalyst to drive Caitlin Snow to become Killer Frost later in the series. The writers are making that a little TOO predictable in the foretelling with this show, especially after the teaser of her in full costume as Killer Frost during the Season 1 finale as well as dropping hints that Cisco will become Vibe at some point too. 

Cool, it's good to see that DC kept some of those extra Bane outfits from
Batman & Robin laying around...

The celebration ends up having more than one buzzkills, with the second being Atomsmasher, played by former WWE Superstar, "Rated R Superstar" Edge/Adam Copeland. I made some people upset on social media when I said that he looked fucking stupid in costume. I'm not kidding. They made him look as lame as Bane in the Batman & Robin film. Once again, I don't dick-ride off of the CW's costume designs for these superhero TV dramas as I personally see their work is hit-or-miss at best in my eyes and this one was a major miss. 

What pissed me off more about Atomsmasher being in this premiere episode was that he was a disposable "villain of the week" character that continues the trend of changing villains weekly like a pair of socks. I'm dying to wonder when people are going to get sick of this Power Rangers-esque style writing for these superhero dramas, especially from DC Comics (Josh Whedon was good for this when he was doing Buffy and Angel regularly too...), where you have the Scooby Doo gang (Team Flash, Team Arrow, and I'm sure that Supergirl is going to have her own support group as well...) that acts as the "support group" for the token hero (or heroine) that helps the hero along with their ongoing angst and trauma with dealing with having powers and special abilities, all while the token "villain of the week" shows up to ruin their day and everything is smiles and ice cream after they are disposed of. Wake up, people, you're literally watching an adult/mature edition of Power Rangers with slightly better special effects and costumes. Well, not so much better special effects on this episode when it came to Atomsmasher's powers as that looked as bad as the Supergirl pilot. 

The entire episode is more focused on Barry's personal melodrama than Atomsmasher's motivations and backstory. In the end, we're left with the clue of "Zoom" was the one who sent him to kill the Flash before Atomsmasher's untimely demise.

Spoiler alert - Eobard Thawne isn't dead as we thought. Professor Zoom is another name for the Reverse Flash. I'm sure what Eddie Thawne did to erase Eobard Thawne from existence did nothing but create a time paradox due to their tampering with time travel and alternate timelines/realities from Season 1, so I'm guessing that Eobard still exists in another reality who still wants the Flash or rather ALL users of the Speed Force (wait I'm getting to that...) dead. I came to this conclusion after noticing that Cisco is still suffering the effects of the "bleeding effect" from seeing events from other timelines/realities. This could be an after-effect of Cisco's "powers" manifesting as his abilities are known in the DC Comics universe as one of the only major threats to the Speed Force, so there's that too to consider. 

Now while we're talking about users of the Speed Force, I bet you're wondering who is that Jay Garrick character who showed up at Star Labs at the end of the episode. Garrick is the "original" Flash that was created by DC Comics, but Barry Allen is always the more "popular" one as Garrick was written off out of continuity or killed off on multiple occasions. I'm anxious to see what they are going to do with him in this season, but I wouldn't be surprised that this leads into adventures into alternate realities and what not.

Watch it or Don't Bother?

Fans of the first season don't have to be told to check this out, but as for sticking around for the long haul? That's up in the air, but there's nothing really bad that stinks to high hell on this premiere. I merely had a lot to rant about in terms of writing and how this stuff was presented. Sue me, I'm a bit more nit-picky on this superhero stuff than most people. 

I want more backstory on Atomsmasher here, but whatever... I do appreciate how they laid out everything for the rest of the season with the foreshadowing of things to come and hints scattered around here and there. I just hope and fear that this isn't as predictable and bloody obvious as most of what was presented in the first season.